The Dangerous Game of Software Imitation When It Comes to Copyrights © , Trademarks ® & Patents

They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. By all accounts, Target was paying homage to one of the greatest video games of

How Target Re-Imagined Video Game, Pong, In Stores...

...And How Atari Sued Them For Trademark & Copyright Infringements

For the past 20 years, on April 26, World Intellectual Property Day has celebrated how IP rights encourage innovation and creativity amongst different sectors.  

They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. 

By all accounts, Target was paying homage to one of the greatest video games of all time when it rolled out “Foot Pong” at several local stores. Instead, its virtualized projection on store floors allowing kids to use their feet to kick the pixelated ball recently incurred a trademark and copyright infringement lawsuit from fading video game giant, Atari Interactive, reflecting the dangerous synergies between software innovation and intellectual property protection for inventors.

The Birth of Pong

When Pong was released decades ago it distinguished itself as the first commercially successful video game and helped forever etch Atari into the iconic stratosphere of pioneering software development companies.  One of the simplest and most elegant games ever invented, it has endured as a symbol of entrepreneurial and technological innovation, building on earlier work by rival Magnavox Odyssey which would later sue Atari for patent infringement.

The two-dimensional game based on table tennis (or ping pong) echoes the early days of Silicon Days when Moore’s Law was still in its infancy and software developers like Allan Alcorn – also an electrical engineer – had to use ingenious ways to extract performance and creativity from limited transistor logic displays found in television sets and in later years, home console gaming devices.  

The launch of the game in arcade parlors across the United States, brought an early financial windfall to Atari.  However, Alcorn, along with the founders Nolan Bushnell and Ted Dabney, did not patent the solid state technology which would ultimately lead to an army of Pong clones invading the marketplace.

Press Play: The Rise of Video Games

Nevertheless, Pong is universally credited for launching the video game industry and continues to hold sentimental value for those old enough to remember it and a new generation of kids who savor its vintage simplicity.  It also recently regained the limelight when Google announced it had used the game to advance its machine learning algorithms that would eventually go on to beat the world’s best players in chess and the Chinese game, Go.

Pong Reborn

 

It’s for this reason that Target’s design and marketing teams rolled out a new virtual incantation of the game at 40 of its stores in and around the children’s clothing and shoes section.   Using a ceiling projector, the ingenious contraption displayed an interactive Pong projection on the floor for kids and parents to hit the ball back and forth with their feet.  

Two vertical lines on the far side of each court are shuffled by the player’s feet to volley the ball back to the opponent, approximating the way the game is played on a video console.  If the player misses the ball, it disappears. A scoreboard at the top of the virtual screen tabulates points during the game.

 

It’s a clever idea  showing us the infinite ways original, older ideas may be re-crafted, re-expressed or repurposed in the software age.    (For an inverse example, read Unlocking The Secrets of the Cube For Inventors, which shows how the vintage toy, Rubik’s Cube, is being re-imagined for puzzle solving as a smart cloud-connected speed cube.)

Unfortunately, Target’s product development team did not fully consult with a software patent & trademark attorney prior to launch, drawing the attention of Atari’s intellectual property team.  In a multi-pronged law suit, Atari claims that Target willfully violated trademarks and copyrights diluting the brand equity of Pong and its value to the Atari product line.

While a cease and desist letter was submitted to Target, the powerful retail brand confirmed it would not retract the Pong projectors from its stores setting up an intriguing legal battle.   

The Case For Atari

Ultimately, Atari is seeking over $2 million in damages from Target claiming the store never sought permission to use the trademarks and copyrights in its limited store rollout.

Many would argue that Atari is a spent force in video game development and unnecessarily seeking damages for a game that no longer has the presence it once did.  It also recently brought a trademark and copyright infringement suit against Nestle for a Kit Kat advertising campaign that includes elements of Atari’s Breakout video game.  

 

Yet these allegations may be a bit unfair considering recent additions to its intellectual property portfolio including Rollercoaster Tycoon® Touch™, a result of its partnership with Theme park operator, Six Flags®.  

Tycoon Touch From Atari

The patented and trademarked mobile application is described as the “most authentic and popular theme park simulation series available” and joins a list of over 200 games developed by the interactive entertainment company including vintage favorites like Asteroids®Centipede®,  and Missile Command®.

From my perspective, the drama unfolding between Target and Atari is also reflective of the poor understanding many small, independent inventors have regarding trademarks and copyrights, including the differences between the two.   Further confusion arises when bringing a patent definition into play, which is one of several reasons why I created one of the largest educational animation libraries on intellectual property in my YouTube patenting channel.

ABOUT TRADEMARKS

These three videos below will introduce you to the concept of trademarks. More videos are available inside my growing YouTube Educational Video Library For Inventors.

A trademark protects a brand, broadly encompassing the name, symbols, words, phrases, designs and logos from competitors who may wish to convert your brand value into commercial profits.

The federally registered trademark confirms the source of goods and services comes from YOU, the inventor and no other entity.   Unlike a patent which expires after 20 years ownership, a trademark can exist in the marketplace forever.  However, the inventor must maintain annual documentation and filing fees.  Competitors  know your software product is trademarked because of the ® symbol after your mark.  If it has not yet been registered,  you can also use what is known as the “common law” trademark which has this ™ symbol.

Tell us about your invention

Call Us Now (1-877-Patent-Professor)
slot77 https://dinsos.bone.go.id/raffi-ahmad/ slot thailand 2025 slot gacor hari ini scatter hitam situs toto slot demo slot777 toto4d https://kowani.or.id/ Slot Gacor Gampang Maxwin slot Slot77 Daun77 Daun77 Daun77 slot mahjong slot77 4d Usutoto demo situs slot gacor slot thailand Slot Terbaik Usutoto Usutoto slot toto slot Daun77 Daun77 Daun77 Akurat77 Akurat77 Akurat77 Akurat77 https://www.twitch.tv/asengbakbak/ https://grillmaster343.gumroad.com/ https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Aseng%20Bak%20Bak https://open.mit.edu/profile/01JJYCB4QXWEWYCWR5FV6TXNS2/ https://www.lanubedocente.21.edu.ar/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.concentra.edu.do/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.tarauaca.ac.gov.br/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.colegioenlinea.edu.co/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.centrotecnologico.edu.mx/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.rodriguesalves.ac.gov.br/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.ceacuautla.edu.mx/profile/yangphnen21/profile https://www.lasallesancristobal.edu.mx/profile/yangphnen21/profile Bajak Laut Beraksi Tebar Angpao Dewa Rezeki Turun Tangan Sambut Imlek Hujan Angpao Dan Permen Sambut Imlek Lucky Neko Kucing Keberuntungan Spaceman Meluncur Ke Bumi Starlight Princess Joget Cantik Menjelang Tahun Baru Imlek, Mahjong Ways Permainan Bangsawan dari China Bagi Hadiah! Teknik Manipulasi Olympus1000 Efektif, Pancing Jepe Keluar Petir x1000! Pola Terbaru Lagi! Ini dia 5 Cara Menang dengan Mudah di Olympus1000! Pergi ke Taman Membeli Bunga, Dapat Jepe Wild Mahjong Ways Langsung Wede Tanpa Bunga! Pola Rahasia Telah Terbongkar! Situs Olympus1000 Ini Lagi Gacohhrr, Menangkan Bray! Rahasia Pecah x1000 di Mahjong Ways yang Jarang Diketahui! Olympus1000: Strategi Gachoor untuk Jepe Mxwin Tanpa Ribet Trik Mahjong Ways 3 agar Scatter Hitam Muncul Lebih Cepat Bagaimana Mendapatkan Jepe Mxwin di Mahjong Ways dengan Mudah Panduan Gachoor Olympus1000: Cara Mendapatkan Pecah x1000 Mahjong Ways 3: Tips Mendekati Scatter Hitam dengan Efektif Jangan Pakai Emosi, Inilah Kunci Sukses Jepe Mxwin di Mahjong Ways! Kamu Harus Coba! Olympus1000 Gachoor: Strategi Jitu Mendapatkan Pecah x1000 Trik Menang di Princess of Starlight Segampang Ini! Trik Rahasia Pola Penarik Jepe x5000! Jepe Mxwin Mahjong Ways: Tips Ampuh Raih Kemenangan Besar Paling Akurat Salad Menciptakan Mood Kuat! Pola Ahli Membawa Kebahagiaan pada Selot Online! Simak Kelucuannya! Pecah x1000 Mahjong Ways 3: Panduan Gachoor Anti Gagal Hari Ini! Strategi Mahjong Ways Terbaru Menjelang Imlek 2025 Jepe Mxwin Sensasional! Rahasia Mendapatkan Scatter Hitam dan Pecah x1000 di Mahjong Ways! Tips Rahasia Mahjong Ways 3 agar Jepe Mxwin Semakin Mencarimu! Cobain Sendiri Biar Tahu! Halubet76 Terungkap! 5 Jurus Ampuh Taklukan Petir Kakek Olympus 5 Trik Populer Pecah di Mahjong Ways dan 7 Alasan Mengapa Game Tersebut Sangat Digemari 7 Fakta Mencenangkan Mahjong Ways yang Jarang Diketahui Orang Pahami Teknik Rahasia Para Sultan Sukses Bermain di Mahjong Online Hacker Bobol Platform Game Online: Rahasia Pola Midas Fortune Terungkap Warga Antusias Bongkar Rahasia Mendapatkan Angpao dari Mahjong Ways dalam Rangka Menyambut Imlek Pemain Sepak Bola Tampan Sukses Menang Besar di Mahjong Ways Pemuda Desa Sukses Taklukan Tantangan Pola Mahjong Ways Bermodal 5 Ribu Rahasia Scatter Mahjong Ways Terungkap, Bule Cantik Kena Jambret di Bali Strategi Akurat Pola Efektif Mencapai Kemenangan Mutlak di Mahjong Ways https://jurnal.lapan.go.id/docs/ https://prod02.generacmobileproducts.com/ Mahjong Ways Jepe x1000, Keberuntungan Dahsyat yang Jarang Terjadi! Bocor Hujan Sketter di Mahjong Ways, Sensasi Baru yang Wajib Dicoba! Jepe Gila-Gilaan di Mahjong Ways! Peluang Besar Menanti Anda Sekarang Mahjong Ways Meledak dengan x1000, Keseruan yang Sulit Dilupakan! Rahasia Mahjong Ways Bocor Jepe x1000 yang Sedang Viral! Nikmati Hujan Sketter Mahjong Ways, Pengalaman Baru yang Tak Terbayangkan Mahjong Ways x1000, Momen Epik yang Siap Mengubah Hidup Anda! Kesempatan Pungut Cuan, Pola Jepe Sensasional Mahjong Ways di Akurat77 Berulah Lagi! Burung Merak Terbang ke Jakarta, Kemenangan Terjamin di Prakmatik Plai! Mahjong Ways Ngambek! Ngasih Wild Ga Henti Tapi Ga Ada yang Tahu! Inilah Waktu G4c0rnya! Olympus1000 Bocor Sketter dan Jepe x1000, Fenomena Ini Sedang Terjadi di Akurat77! Momen Langka! Olympus1000 Hujan Sketter yang Tak Diduga Petrik Kini Terbuka! Rasakan Jepe x1000 Olympus1000, Petualangan yang Mengguncang Adrenalin Olympus1000 Bocor Jepe Gila-Gilaan, Ini Dia Pola Rahasia Kemenangan Untuk Anda! Keajaiban Olympus1000: Hujan Sketter yang Membawa Keberuntungan Besar Sensasional! Peluang Kemenangan di Olympus1000 Terbuka! Inilah Saatnya Anda Cuan Hebat! Hujan Sketter di Olympus1000, Kakek Zeus Mengamuk Dikasih Hadiah Kemarahan Petir Jepe! Rahasia Dikasih Kejutan Mxwin Jepe x500 oleh Olympus1000, Ini Dia Cara yang Harus Kamu Cobain! Olympus1000 Bocor Sketter dan x1000, Sensasi Tak Tertandingi Ada di Sini! Serunya Olympus1000 Jepe Gila, Dikasih Spin Puas Hujan Sketter Berjejeran! Tiru Pola Ini Dalam Mahjong Ways Pola Rahasia Mahjong Ways Gempar Fitur Sketer Hitam Diretas Kejayaan Meraih Sketer Hitam Mahjong Ways Luncurkan Strategi Menaklukkan Starlight Princess Pola Andalan Usutoto Menaklukkan Princess Starlight Alasan Starlight Princess Mengamuk Hujan Lapuk! Kabar Viral Fufufafa Membuat Mahjong Ways Kembali Mengamuk Beri Jepe X100! Meroket! Keberhasilan Pelantikan Trump Membuat Pumping Mahjong Ways! Ini Selengkapnya! Mencari Buah Semangka: Inilah Trik Menang Pola Mahjong Ways yang Tidak Disangka! Pola Ini Kasih Jepe Paus Wild Sampai Banjir-Banjir! Mahjong Ways Beri Hujan FS! Kocak Abis! Pemenang Mahjong Ways Adi Sampai Goyang Dumang! Naga Emas Sampai Muncul! Bisikan Si Gobel! Tips dan Trik Pola Rahasia Kemenangan di Mahjong Ways 2 situs Akurat77 Dibocorkan! Kemayoran Kebakaran! Inilah 2 Pola Jepe Sketter yang Akan Memunculkan Naga Emas Permainan Mahjong Ways! Disangka Tidak Kompeten! Budi Beberkan Alasan Ia Berhenti Bekerja Demi Wild Mahjong! Panduan & Cara Akurat Memakai Pola Wede Jamin Kaya di Mahjong Ways 2025! Tips Para Ahli: Pakai Ratusan Pola Tapi Belum Wede di Mahjong Ways? Inilah Caranya! DWV99 DWV138 DWVGAMING METTA4D MBAK4D MBAK4D MBAK4D METTA4D METTA4D METTA4D METTA4D demo slot MBAK4D METTA4D MINI1221 https://icosa.umy.ac.id/wp-content/assets/ 5 Hal Ini Ternyata Membesarkan Peluang Kemenangan di Mahjong Ways! Tuntas Sudah! Pola Rahasia Ini Pasti Kasih Menang! Skater Hitam Pasti Turun. Kode Rahasia Dipecahkan! Mrs. Mimi Ungkap Dapat Jackpot Sehari 5 Kali! Usai Jepe Paus di Mahjong Ways, Mr Zack Bocorkan Pola Rahasianya! Ayo Cari Tahu! Aloe Pemulus Muka, Inilah Teknik Curangi Mahjong Ways yang Bikin Murka! 3 Strategi Curangi Mahjong Ways Hingga Dapat Hujan Scatter Hitam! Pergi ke Sawah Menanam Padi, Inilah Fitur Rahasia Mahjong Ways yang Harus Kamu Cobain! Ramalan Bintang! Inilah 5 Zodiak yang Diprediksi Pasti G4c0r di Mahjong Ways! Meresahkan Pecinta Selot! Mahjong Ways Kembali Mengamuk, Hujan Wild Dimana-mana! Strategi Akurat Memenangkan Mahjong Ways, Pola Jitu Pasti Sketter! Viral Game Princess Khusus LAKIK! Jepe Wangi Sedang Menanti! Pagi Cerah Bersama Kakek Petir, 5 Pola yang Akan Membuatmu Menggelintir! Jepe Maksimal di Olympus1000! Andi Bocorkan Rahasia Kemenangannya! Berburu Sketter Hitam dari Mahjong Ways, Ternyata Ini Rahasianya! Sangat Mudah! Mexwin Sensasional Hanya Pake Pola Ini! Rahasia Kemenangan Jitu Olympus1000! Dikasih Spin Puas Ama Kakek Olympus! Pola Pasti G4c0r yang Wajib Kamu Coba! Hujan Perkalian! Teknik Ini Bikin Hujan Petir Bersama Kakek Olympus1000! Rajin Ternak Pola, Abangda Berhasil Meraih Maxwin di Olympus1000! 10 Pola Terakurat yang Terbukti Memenangkan Budi di Starlight Princess! Berhasil Meraih Kemenangan Besar Pada Mahjong Ways! Pemuda Ini Sampai Pingsan Karena Shock! Rahasia Sukses Bermain Kakek Olympus1000 yang Perlu Anda Ketahui Panduan Lengkap Kakek Olympus1000: Cara Menang Mudah dan Cepat Mengungkap Strategi Kakek Olympus1000 untuk Pemain Pemula Trik Kakek Olympus1000 yang Bisa Membantu Anda Menang Lebih Sering Kenapa Kakek Olympus1000 Menjadi Pilihan Utama Penggemar Game? Taktik Terbaik untuk Meningkatkan Kemenangan di Kakek Olympus1000 Kakek Olympus1000: Cara Memanfaatkan Fitur-Fitur Khusus untuk Keuntungan Mengapa Kakek Olympus1000 Populer di Kalangan Gamer? Ini Penjelasannya Kakek Olympus1000: Langkah-langkah Mudah untuk Mencapai Menang Besar Tips Terbaik untuk Bermain Kakek Olympus1000 dengan Lebih Cermat Inilah Mengapa Kakek Olympus1000 Menjadi Permainan Favorit Banyak Orang Cara Menjadi Ahli dalam Kakek Olympus1000: Tips dari Pemain Berpengalaman 5 Hal yang Harus Anda Ketahui Sebelum Bermain Kakek Olympus1000 Kakek Olympus1000: Memahami Fitur Unik yang Membuatnya Menarik Strategi Jitu untuk Meraih Kemenangan Konsisten di Kakek Olympus1000 Mengoptimalkan Peluang Menang di Kakek Olympus1000 dengan Langkah Mudah Rahasia di Balik Kesuksesan Kakek Olympus1000 yang Wajib Anda Coba Kakek Olympus1000: Cara Memaksimalkan Setiap Putaran untuk Hasil Maksimal Trik Cerdas Memahami Pola di Kakek Olympus1000 untuk Meningkatkan Peluang Anda Tradisi Imlek Modern Angpao Trik Pamungkas PG Soft Viral Bocah Hilang Kesadaran Imlek Meriah Pahlawan Langit Beri Angpao togel malaysia sabung ayam online Rayakan Imlek Bersama Koboi Jejeran USUTOTO Perkalian Pecah Princess Starlight Terupdate Auto Kaya Cara Agar Hujan Petir Auto Cuan Starlight Princess 100% Jitu dan Pasti Terjadi Jebol Cara Starlight Princess Ngasih Perkalian Hujan x500 Langsung Dapat Sketer Mahjong Ways Auto Tajir Tanpa Buy Spin Viral Buruan Coba Starlight Princess! Ngamuk Auto Turun x1000 Yang Dicari Banyak Warga Bandung Teknik Jitu Mengalahkan Mahjong Ways, Ampuh Turun Sketer Hitam Dari Jualan Rujak ke Puncak Kesuksesan: Perjalanan Warga Tanjungbalai Menjadi Miliarder Bersama Usutoto Waspada Mahjong Ways Bagi Sketer Tanpa Batas Bersama Akurat77 tototogel slot88 MBAK4D MBAK4D DWV138 METTA4D gameslot berita5 indonewsupdate